The extensive, and at times extensively weird, burger menu always seems popular, as do the fry options served up. Where else can you order a "dumpster burger and crab fries?" You can always get regular fries, but it's worth it to take the opportunity to try something different.
But the part of the menu which jumped out at me is sandwiched (how appropriate) between hot and cold sandwiches and steak sandwiches. Moogy's has cornered the market on chicken steak. It sounds weird, but just trust your gut and order one of these chicken-and-whatever subs. Your gut will thank you.
If by some chance you find yourself wide awake before noon on a weekend morning, Moogy's breakfast would be one of the best possible ways to kick-off your day. But for that matter, why leave it to breakfast? The omelets, French toast sandwiches, and breakfast platters make you feel like signing up for a free trial of cholesterol meds after just reading their names, but hey, it's probably worth it.
I myself anxiously await the day I can order a mimosa at Moogy's (yes, a mimosa) and an omelet, and relax to the crash of Connect Four chips.